
Episode 53
Education
1:55:23
Inside Oregon School Boards: Who Really Controls Education?
Michael Summers
Redmond School Board
ABOUT THIS EPISODE
What does an Oregon school board actually control — and how much is determined in Salem? Mike McLane sits down with Redmond School Board Vice Chair Michael Summers for a detailed look inside local education governance. They discuss curriculum, school budgets, parental involvement, classroom discipline, cell phones, teacher negotiations, special education, state mandates, and the limits of “local control” in Oregon public schools.
SHOW NOTES
What Can Oregon School Boards Actually Control?
School boards appear on ballots across Oregon. Voters elect them, parents attend their meetings, and board members often become the first people blamed when something goes wrong in a public school.
But how much authority does an Oregon school board actually have?
That question is at the center of this episode of Oregon Discussion. State Senator Mike McLane sits down with Michael Summers, a longtime Central Oregon small-business owner who was elected to the Redmond School Board in 2021 and now serves as its vice chair.
Their conversation offers a detailed look at the layers of Oregon’s education system: what local boards decide, what the Legislature requires, what the Oregon Department of Education controls, what teachers and administrators negotiate, and how those pieces ultimately affect students and families.
Why Michael Summers Ran for School Board
Summers joined the Redmond School Board during one of the most contentious periods in modern public education.
COVID-era closures had transformed school-board meetings around the country into political battlegrounds. Parents were frustrated over closures, curriculum, masks, remote learning and the broader direction of public education.
Summers says he did not enter the race wanting to become a political combatant. He describes himself as a small-business owner, father and “bridge builder” who felt that schools were too important to communities to become permanent sites of political warfare.
His first board meeting came in a hot auditorium filled with hundreds of frustrated people on opposing sides of the issues.
That experience helped shape what Summers says became one of his guiding principles: school boards should become “boring” again — focused on student outcomes rather than political spectacle.
Schools as the Center of a Community
The episode spends time on why school governance matters even to people who do not currently have children enrolled.
Summers is a third-generation owner of Summers Flooring in Central Oregon. He argues that schools are part of the economic infrastructure of a community because today’s students become tomorrow’s workers, customers, business owners and civic leaders.
For employers, basic literacy, numeracy, reliability and character are not theoretical educational goals. They directly affect whether a future workforce can function.
That makes education both a family issue and an economic-development issue.
Who Is Actually in Charge of Oregon Education?
Oregon’s education governance structure is more centralized than many voters may realize.
Under Oregon law, the governor serves as Superintendent of Public Instruction. The governor appoints a deputy superintendent to run the Oregon Department of Education, and the State Board of Education sets statewide policies and standards that local districts must follow.
Local boards still have meaningful responsibilities, including hiring and evaluating the superintendent, adopting budgets, approving curriculum selections, setting local policies and providing overall governance.
But Summers says one of the first lessons he learned after joining the board was that “local control” has significant limits. Many requirements are established in statute, administrative rule or statewide standards. A local board cannot simply decide to ignore state law because its community disagrees with it.
That distinction becomes a major theme throughout the episode.
The Curriculum Question
One of the most useful portions of the conversation explains how curriculum is adopted.
Summers says Oregon typically provides districts with a group of state-approved curriculum options that meet statewide standards. District educators then review and pilot materials before recommending a selection.
A district can choose something outside the pre-approved list, but doing so requires considerably more work to demonstrate that the alternative curriculum meets state requirements.
That means the local board has a choice — but not an unlimited one.
Summers says Redmond has attempted to emphasize transparency by making proposed curriculum available for parents and community members to review before adoption, including both physical materials and digital resources.
For him, transparency is partly about preventing distrust. Parents are far more likely to become alarmed when they believe important decisions about their children are being made behind closed doors.
COVID Gave Parents a Window Into the Classroom
Both McLane and Summers argue that COVID dramatically changed parental involvement in education.
Remote learning placed classrooms directly inside homes. Parents who previously saw assignments, report cards and occasional homework suddenly heard lectures and classroom conversations firsthand.
Summers describes overhearing one of his daughter’s American-history lessons and becoming concerned about how material was framed. His concern was not simply that difficult historical subjects were being discussed, but that he felt a particular interpretation was being presented rather than explored through questions and competing perspectives.
That experience contributed to his decision to become more involved.
Academic Fundamentals and Limited Instructional Time
Summers repeatedly returns to what he sees as an opportunity-cost problem.
Schools have a limited number of instructional hours. Every new mandate, program or curricular topic takes time.
His argument is that Oregon should prioritize reading, mathematics, science and civics before adding additional mandates. In his view, debates over controversial curriculum become even harder to justify when students are struggling in core academic areas.
Oregon does administer statewide English-language arts and math assessments in grades 3–8 and 11 and science assessments in grades 5, 8 and 11, providing state, district and school-level performance data.
The broader question is how policymakers respond to that data — and whether statewide priorities remain centered on academic proficiency.
School Choice and Parents Leaving the System
Summers says Redmond saw significant enrollment changes following the pandemic as families considered homeschooling, online charter schools, private education and other alternatives.
His view is that parents should have meaningful choices and that public schools should have to earn families’ confidence.
The episode also discusses the concept often called “backpack funding” — allowing education funding to follow a student to a different educational option. Summers presents this as a way to increase competition and parental choice.
That idea remains politically contested. Supporters argue that it empowers families and encourages competition; critics argue that redirecting public funds can weaken traditional public-school systems.
The episode does not resolve that debate, but it illustrates why school choice has become increasingly central to education politics.
Can School Boards Reject State Curriculum?
Not easily.
Summers explains that if educators and board members conclude that none of Oregon’s approved curricula adequately serves their students, the district can look elsewhere — but the alternative must still demonstrate compliance with state standards.
That requires staff time, review, piloting and documentation.
The practical result, he says, is that districts often operate within a fairly constrained menu of choices.
That is another example of the tension between statewide consistency and local control.
Cell Phones: A Local Policy Summers Says Worked
One area where Summers describes a clear local success is cell-phone policy.
Redmond moved toward a bell-to-bell restriction on student cell-phone use. Summers says teachers welcomed the change because they no longer spent large portions of class time policing phones, while students began interacting more with one another during lunch and throughout the school day.
Gov. Tina Kotek subsequently issued a statewide directive requiring districts to establish policies restricting personal electronic-device use during the school day.
For Summers, the Redmond experience is an example of a relatively straightforward rule producing tangible classroom benefits.
Technology Can Help — But Screens Are Not Education
The episode distinguishes cell phones from educational technology.
Summers notes that student Chromebooks and digital programs can allow teachers to track individual progress, identify learning gaps and provide targeted interventions.
That is an important benefit.
At the same time, the episode raises the larger question of whether schools have become too dependent on screens and technology when traditional teacher-student interaction remains essential.
The more useful framing may not be “technology good” or “technology bad,” but rather whether technology helps students achieve a specific educational outcome.
Classroom Discipline and Special Education
One of the more difficult sections of the episode concerns classroom behavior.
Summers says educators sometimes face violent or highly disruptive behavior, particularly when serving students with severe disabilities. He argues that state rules can limit certain physical interventions even in situations where a child may be endangering themselves, other students or staff.
The result, he says, can sometimes be “room clears,” where an entire classroom is evacuated until the situation is safe again.
Summers argues that this can harm everyone involved: the child in crisis, the special-education teacher, and other students whose learning is interrupted.
This is an area where policy requires particular care. Students with disabilities have significant federal and state protections, and restraint or seclusion carries serious safety and civil-rights implications. At the same time, districts must also provide safe environments for students and employees.
The tension illustrates why school governance is often more complicated than political slogans suggest.
Teachers and Collective Bargaining
Summers also discusses collective bargaining from the perspective of a board member and employer.
He is careful to distinguish teachers from the organizations representing them. He repeatedly says Redmond has excellent teachers and argues that educators need competitive compensation, useful training and appropriate classroom resources.
But he is critical of what he sees as the political role of teachers’ unions and argues that negotiations can become disconnected from measurable student outcomes.
That is Summers’ perspective; teachers’ unions generally argue that working conditions, compensation, staffing levels and class sizes directly affect the quality of education students receive.
The episode therefore exposes one of the central tensions in public education: employees understandably organize around their employment interests, while school boards are responsible for balancing employee needs against budgets and student outcomes.
School Budgets Are More Complicated Than They Look
A recurring theme is the gap between headline spending figures and money actually available inside classrooms.
Summers discusses several major pressures:
PERS obligations.
Special-education costs that exceed state reimbursement.
Mental and behavioral-health services.
Grant administration.
Personnel costs.
State mandates.
He notes that the overwhelming majority of Redmond’s budget goes to personnel and that special-education services can require significant spending beyond what districts receive in dedicated funding.
That helps explain why simply dividing statewide education spending by student enrollment does not reveal how much money a classroom teacher actually has available.
Special Education and Unfunded Costs
Summers is particularly concerned about special education.
Public schools must educate students with disabilities. He makes clear that these students deserve appropriate care and education.
His concern is the funding structure.
A student with intensive needs may require multiple staff members, specialized transportation, behavioral supports or other services costing far more than average per-pupil funding. Once dedicated reimbursement reaches certain limits, local districts must cover the difference from their general funds.
That means money that could otherwise be used elsewhere in the district is redirected to meet a legal and moral obligation the district cannot avoid.
Summers’ proposed solution is not to provide less service. It is to fund those obligations honestly.
The Ten-Pillar Education Reform Framework
Near the end of the episode, Summers walks through a ten-pillar framework developed by Oregon school superintendents.
The conversation touches on several themes:
A consistent long-term vision for education.
Better and more useful measurement of student achievement.
High-quality early learning.
Adequate support for high-cost student populations.
More pathways into the teaching profession.
Greater emphasis on instructional time.
Professional development that actually improves teaching.
Predictable school funding.
Mental and behavioral-health capacity.
A more coherent statewide education system.
Summers likes the framework because it attempts to answer a different question from the typical political debate:
What would Oregon have to do to become one of the best-performing education systems in the country?
Better Measures of Student Achievement
One pillar Summers emphasizes is assessment.
Oregon already administers statewide assessments, but Summers argues the current system does not always produce sufficiently useful or timely information, particularly when participation varies. Oregon's Department of Education publishes statewide, district and school assessment results and participation data for English language arts, mathematics and science.
His preferred approach would make testing more meaningful to both the system and students, allowing districts to measure improvement rather than simply generate another compliance requirement.
Teacher Preparation and Alternative Pathways
Another pillar addresses how teachers enter the profession.
Summers questions whether every teaching role should require the same traditional graduate-school pathway and argues that experienced professionals in engineering, trades or other fields could bring valuable practical knowledge into classrooms.
His argument is not that teaching requires no specialized skill. Rather, he asks whether Oregon could build additional pathways that combine teaching expertise with real-world subject-matter experience.
That idea could be especially relevant in career and technical education, where industry experience may be particularly valuable.
Reading Instruction and Professional Development
Summers also discusses the renewed emphasis on phonics and the “science of reading.”
His point is that teachers are often being asked to implement approaches they were never trained to use. Rather than blaming teachers for results produced by prior educational theories, he argues districts should provide focused coaching and professional development based on methods that demonstrate better outcomes.
This echoes a broader national shift toward evidence-based early literacy instruction.
Too Much Administrative Work?
The final reform area involves bureaucracy.
Summers says school districts employ staff specifically to manage grants, reporting requirements and compliance documentation because large portions of education funding come with specific conditions.
Those requirements may exist for legitimate accountability reasons, but every hour spent documenting compliance is an hour — and a salary — that is not directly providing instruction.
His argument is for a simpler, more predictable system that still holds schools accountable for outcomes while reducing unnecessary administrative work.
The Real Job of a School Board
Perhaps the clearest lesson in this episode is that a school board is neither powerless nor all-powerful.
A board cannot rewrite Oregon law.
It cannot ignore statewide education standards.
It cannot independently redesign the state funding formula.
But it can:
Choose and evaluate the superintendent.
Set local priorities.
Approve budgets.
Review curriculum.
Demand transparency.
Set district culture.
Ask hard questions.
Create policies in areas where local discretion exists.
And, perhaps most importantly, represent the community to the institution rather than merely represent the institution to the community.
That is why school-board elections matter.
Conclusion: Make School Boards About Schools Again
Summers repeatedly returns to one phrase: keep the main thing the main thing.
For him, the primary mission of public education is straightforward: prepare students to read, reason, calculate, communicate, participate in civic life and succeed as adults.
The challenge is that school systems are increasingly asked to perform many additional roles — mental-health provider, social-service provider, technology provider, behavioral intervention system and more.
Some of those services may be necessary.
But every expansion brings costs, staffing requirements and tradeoffs.
The central question raised by this episode is therefore not simply whether Oregon spends enough on education.
It is whether Oregon has clearly defined what its public schools are supposed to accomplish — and whether every layer of the system, from the governor to the local school board, is organized around achieving those outcomes.
What does an Oregon school board actually control?
Chapters
01:20 What School Boards Actually Do
05:46 Why Michael Summers Ran During COVID
13:07 Instructional Time, Curriculum & Academic Priorities
19:28 What Parents Saw During COVID
23:19 Bringing Balance Back to School Boards
30:08 The Limits of Local Control
38:11 How Curriculum Is Chosen in Oregon
40:42 School Choice, Homeschooling & Parent Options
46:09 How Schools Teach American History
1:01:24 State Mandates vs. Core Academics
1:05:26 Teachers Unions & Collective Bargaining
1:15:18 School Budgets, PERS & Special Education
1:18:44 Cell Phones, Screens & Classroom Discipline
1:27:50 Why School Board Races Became Political
1:29:37 A 10-Point Plan to Improve Oregon Education
1:40:29 Why Schools Spend More With Fewer Students
1:47:39 Why Good People Should Run for School Board
1:48:40 Why Michael Summers Is Running for HD 53
1:54:39 Final Thoughts