Episode 49

Health care

1:05:53

Oregon’s Mental Health Crisis: Spending More, Ranking Last

Angela Plowhead

Guest

ABOUT THIS EPISODE

In this episode of Oregon Discussion, Mike McLane and Shelly Boshart-Davis are joined by Angela Plowhead to examine Oregon’s worsening mental health crisis. The conversation covers behavioral health spending, provider shortages, youth mental health, veteran suicide, parental rights, nonprofit accountability, and why Oregon ranks last in the nation despite major public investment.

SHOW NOTES

Oregon’s Mental Health Crisis: Why Spending More Has Not Produced Better Results

Oregon is spending heavily on behavioral health, mental health services, addiction treatment, crisis response, and related programs. Yet according to the discussion in this episode of Oregon Discussion, Oregon ranks 51st out of 51 — including Washington, D.C. — for prevalence of mental illness and substance use issues.

That contrast drives the entire conversation.

In this episode, hosts Mike McLane and Shelly Boshart-Davis are joined by Angela Plowhead, a clinical psychologist, Air Force veteran, veteran advocate, and founder of Stay Alive Vets. The conversation focuses on a difficult but necessary question: if Oregon is spending so much money on mental health and behavioral health, why are the results still so poor?

Oregon Ranks Last in Mental Health Outcomes

The episode opens with one of the most serious data points discussed on Oregon Discussion: Oregon ranks dead last for mental illness and substance use prevalence.

McLane and Boshart-Davis frame this as a government accountability issue. The state has spent roughly $1.35 billion in recent years to improve behavioral health, including areas such as aid and assist, crisis intervention, Measure 110-related programs, and behavioral health workforce efforts. Yet the hosts argue that the outcomes have not matched the investment.

The concern is not whether mental health matters. Everyone in the conversation agrees that it does. The concern is whether Oregon’s policies are helping people effectively — or whether the state is spending large sums while failing to deliver measurable improvement.

Youth Mental Health Is Especially Concerning

Angela Plowhead emphasizes that Oregon’s ranking is not only troubling at the adult level. Youth mental health is also a serious concern.

The episode connects youth mental health to other challenges already discussed in previous Oregon Discussion episodes, including youth homelessness, school disconnection, family instability, and the consequences of COVID-era isolation.

Plowhead argues that Oregon has laws and policies that can make it harder for parents to support children during mental health struggles. This becomes one of the strongest themes of the episode: when children are struggling, parents should not be treated as outsiders by default.

Provider Shortages and Licensing Barriers

A major policy issue discussed in the episode is Oregon’s shortage of mental health providers.

Plowhead explains that Oregon does not have the same level of licensure portability that many other states allow. She points to PsyPact, an interstate compact that allows licensed psychologists to provide telehealth services across participating states. According to the discussion, 38 states participate, but Oregon does not.

This matters because telehealth could give Oregonians access to mental health providers outside the state, especially when local access is limited. But Oregon’s licensing rules can prevent that.

For patients, that means fewer choices. For providers, it means more administrative barriers. For the state, it means Oregon is making access harder at a time when demand is already high.

Why Recruiting Mental Health Providers Is Difficult

The conversation also looks at why it is hard to recruit mental health providers to Oregon.

Plowhead discusses several barriers:

Oregon’s high cost of living

High tax burden

Expensive and slow licensing processes

Insurance credentialing delays

Long waits before reimbursement

Business-related taxes and administrative costs

She explains that a provider may spend months getting licensed and credentialed before seeing patients and receiving reimbursement. That delay can make it very difficult for new providers to start or sustain a practice.

This is a practical issue. If Oregon wants more mental health access, it must make it easier for qualified providers to serve patients.

Insurance and CCO Access Problems

The episode also raises concerns about coordinated care organizations and insurance reimbursement.

Plowhead discusses how decisions by certain health plans can restrict access to non-preferred behavioral health providers. Mike McLane connects that concern to issues in Eastern Oregon, where patient choice became a major problem after a CCO policy change.

The broader point is that “access” does not mean much if patients are technically covered but cannot actually see the provider they need.

If Oregon wants better outcomes, access must be real, not just written into a program description.

Measure 110 and the Nonprofit Accountability Problem

The episode also returns to a recurring Oregon Discussion theme: what happens when taxpayer dollars leave the state and go to nonprofits or outside organizations.

Plowhead discusses Measure 110 and the Oregon Health Authority’s role in distributing money. She raises concerns that some funds were not distributed effectively, while other funds went to nonprofit organizations without adequate vetting or accountability.

McLane and Boshart-Davis connect this to what they often call the nonprofit industrial complex — the system where public dollars flow into nonprofits, but the public may not have a clear way to measure outcomes, follow the money, or confirm whether services are actually being delivered.

Plowhead contrasts that with her own nonprofit, Stay Alive Vets, which vets organizations, requires reporting, tracks how many veterans are served, and looks at whether money is used for direct services.

That raises an important public policy question: if small nonprofits can track outcomes and require accountability, why can’t the state?

Veteran Suicide and the Need for Community

One of the most personal parts of the episode centers on veterans.

Plowhead, an Air Force veteran, explains that her nonprofit work focuses on veteran suicide prevention. She discusses the importance of belonging, community, purpose, and connection for veterans transitioning out of military life.

The episode notes that veterans often carry intense responsibility at a young age. Many served in high-stress environments, made life-and-death decisions, and developed a strong sense of mission and community. After leaving the service, some struggle to find that same purpose, structure, and belonging.

Plowhead argues that preventing veteran suicide is not only about clinical services. It is also about helping veterans rebuild community and meaning.

Mental Illness, Homelessness, and Civil Commitment

The conversation also connects mental illness to homelessness.

Plowhead discusses Oregon’s civil commitment process and argues that it is difficult to intervene even when people are visibly in crisis. She describes situations where people experiencing psychosis may be harming themselves, disturbing public spaces, or frightening community members, but may still not meet the legal threshold for involuntary commitment.

The episode also discusses the shortage of beds and residential placements for people with serious and chronic mental illness. Plowhead points to Oregon’s certificate of need process as one barrier to expanding psychiatric capacity.

The concern is that Oregon has people in severe mental health crisis, but not enough practical options to get them into stable care.

Certificate of Need and the Bed Shortage

A major structural issue discussed is Oregon’s certificate of need system.

Plowhead argues that this process can prevent new psychiatric beds or specialized care facilities from opening. She gives the example of a proposed geriatric psychiatric ward that was blocked years ago, despite the need for more services.

This raises a broader policy issue: if Oregon does not have enough beds, residential treatment capacity, or appropriate placements, then people with serious mental illness may end up cycling through homelessness, emergency rooms, jails, or crisis systems instead of receiving consistent care.

Hospice Reform and Rural Access

The episode also covers hospice policy, including Senate Bill 1575.

Plowhead describes the bill as a hospice reform effort intended to address fraud, but argues that it does not go far enough to punish bad actors while also creating barriers for legitimate providers who want to serve rural communities.

Her concern is that rural areas already struggle to access hospice services. A broad moratorium or poorly targeted reform can make that problem worse if it prevents legitimate providers from entering underserved areas.

This is one of the episode’s recurring points: laws written to solve one problem can create new problems if policymakers do not understand the practical consequences.

Legislating to the Exception

One of the strongest themes in the episode is what Plowhead calls legislating to the minority or lowest common denominator.

She discusses laws intended to protect children in abusive homes by allowing minors to access certain services without parental involvement. The concern, however, is that Oregon created broad laws affecting all families, not just the small number of cases where parents are abusive.

The episode argues that this has created a system where parents can be pushed out of decisions involving their child’s mental health or medical care.

McLane frames this as a larger worldview problem: Oregon policy too often assumes government is a better parent than parents themselves.

Parental Notification and Youth Mental Health

The discussion then turns to parental notification in schools.

Shelly Boshart-Davis tells the story of legislation introduced by Christine Drazan that would have required parents to be notified if their child was being bullied at school. According to the episode, the bill did not move at first, but later passed unanimously after the suicide of a child named Carson, whose parents said they had not been notified that he was being bullied.

The point is not only about one bill. It is about how political control and partisanship can prevent common-sense policies from moving forward until after tragedy occurs.

For the hosts, this is one of the clearest examples of what is wrong in Oregon policymaking: good ideas should not be blocked simply because they come from the wrong party.

Youth Medical Privacy and Parent Access

Plowhead also discusses parent access to children’s medical information.

She explains that in some cases, parents can lose access to medical portals or records for children at young ages, even while the parent remains financially responsible for insurance, care, and bills.

The episode describes this as inconsistent and harmful. Parents may be expected to pay for care but may not have full access to information needed to support their child.

The broader concern is that Oregon’s approach can isolate children from family support at exactly the moment when family involvement may be most important.

Reproductive Health, Abuse, and Trafficking Concerns

The conversation also covers youth reproductive health policy.

Plowhead raises serious concerns that allowing minors to receive certain reproductive health services without parental knowledge may create opportunities for abusers or traffickers to hide evidence of exploitation.

This is one of the most sensitive topics in the episode, and it is framed as a child-safety concern rather than a simple political issue. The argument is that policies meant to protect youth autonomy must also account for the reality of abuse, coercion, trafficking, and fear.

A system that excludes parents entirely can unintentionally protect abusers instead of children.

COVID, Isolation, and the Elderly

The episode also touches on the impact of COVID-era isolation on the elderly and people with dementia.

Plowhead explains that isolation from family and community was especially damaging for dementia patients. She notes that some patients declined significantly during lockdowns and did not regain their previous functioning.

The conversation also discusses the pain of people dying without family contact, being cared for by masked providers, and losing the human connection that is so important at the end of life.

This part of the episode reinforces the larger theme: human connection is not optional. It is central to mental health, aging, care, and dignity.

Community as a Mental Health Solution

Across the episode, Plowhead repeatedly returns to the importance of community.

She argues that strong connections to family, support networks, churches, veteran groups, local organizations, and community institutions improve outcomes across mental health, education, and healthcare.

In her view, Oregon’s policies have too often weakened or bypassed those relationships. Government cannot replace family and community. At best, government should support the conditions where family and community can do their work.

Conclusion: Oregon Must Stop Measuring Success by Spending

This episode of Oregon Discussion argues that Oregon’s mental health crisis is not simply a funding problem.

The state has spent large amounts of money. The programs exist. Agencies have been tasked with improving behavioral health. Nonprofits receive public funds. Yet Oregon remains last in the nation on key mental health and substance use measures.

The episode’s conclusion is clear: Oregon needs better results, not just bigger budgets.

That means:

More provider access

Licensing reform

Telehealth flexibility

Better nonprofit accountability

More psychiatric and residential capacity

Civil commitment reform

Stronger parental notification

Support for veterans

Community-based solutions

A willingness to admit current policies are not working

Oregon’s mental health crisis affects families, veterans, youth, homeless individuals, schools, seniors, and communities across the state. If leaders want better outcomes, they will have to stop defending failed systems and start asking whether real people are actually getting the help they need.

Chapters

  • 02:06 Welcome to Oregon Discussion

  • 02:22 Why This Episode Focuses on Mental Health

  • 03:48 Meet Dr. Angela Plowhead

  • 04:16 Angela’s Air Force and Clinical Psychology Background

  • 06:33 Veteran Suicide Prevention and Stay Alive Vets

  • 08:37 Oregon Ranks 51st in Mental Health

  • 09:42 Youth Mental Health and Homelessness

  • 10:32 Spending $1.35 Billion, Ranking Last

  • 11:28 Licensing Barriers and Provider Shortages

  • 13:01 CCOs, Insurance, and Patient Choice

  • 13:24 Telehealth Access and Oregon Restrictions

  • 15:03 Recruiting Providers in a High-Cost State

  • 16:52 Measure 110 and OHA Accountability

  • 18:12 How Stay Alive Vets Tracks Results

  • 18:44 Suicide, Overdose, and Rural Mental Health

  • 19:42 Homelessness and Serious Mental Illness

  • 21:51 Hospice Reform and Rural Access

  • 26:18 Healthcare Committee Power and Accountability

  • 27:30 Veteran Suicide and the Need for Belonging

  • 31:37 What the State Can Do for Veterans

  • 33:07 Why Oregon’s Crisis May Be Cultural

  • 34:56 Family, Community, and Mental Health

  • 36:22 Youth Mental Health and Parental Consent

  • 37:07 When Parents Are Left Out

  • 38:21 Legislating From Empathy Without Discipline

  • 39:27 Teen Healthcare Decisions Without Parents

  • 42:08 Parent Access to Medical Information

  • 46:56 Youth Reproductive Health and Safety Concerns

  • 50:38 Stop Digging the Policy Hole

  • 51:19 The Bullying Notification Bill and Carson’s Story

  • 53:59 Needles Near Schools and Partisan Roadblocks

  • 56:09 When Good Ideas Get Blocked

  • 57:15 Why Angela Got Involved in Politics

  • 59:15 COVID Isolation and Dementia Patients

  • 1:01:04 The Long-Term Damage of School Closures

  • 1:03:13 Crisis Resources for Veterans and Others

  • 1:03:52 Common Sense Institute Data

  • 1:05:30 Final Thoughts

Listen to the full audio episode

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.