Episode 38

Budget & taxes

1:09:15

The CAT Tax: Promises vs Reality in Oregon

Justin Brecht

Guest

ABOUT THIS EPISODE

In this episode of Oregon Discussion, Mike McLane and Shelly Boshart-Davis break down Oregon’s Corporate Activity Tax (CAT) and the Student Success Act. Joined by legislative director Justin Brecht, they examine whether the tax delivered on its promises—and what the data shows about education funding, accountability, and rising costs.

SHOW NOTES

The CAT Tax and Oregon’s Student Success Act: What Happened?

Oregon’s Corporate Activity Tax (CAT), passed in 2019 as part of the Student Success Act, was sold to voters and lawmakers as a major investment in education. The promise was simple: new revenue would lead to improved student outcomes.

In this episode of Oregon D.O.G.E., hosts Mike McLane and Shelly Boshart-Davis, joined by legislative director Justin Brecht take a closer look at whether that promise has been fulfilled—and what the data reveals about how education funding actually works in Oregon.

What Is the CAT Tax?

The CAT tax is a gross receipts tax, meaning it is applied to sales rather than profits. This distinction is critical.

Unlike traditional business taxes, companies must pay the CAT tax regardless of whether they are profitable. As discussed in the episode, this means:

  • Businesses can be taxed even when losing money

  • Costs are often passed along to consumers

  • The tax applies at multiple stages in the supply chain

This structure has led critics to describe the CAT tax as a “backdoor sales tax.”

Voter Rejection and Legislative Action

Before the CAT tax was enacted, Oregon voters had already rejected a similar proposal—Measure 97—in 2016.

Despite that rejection, the legislature passed the CAT tax in 2019 under a different name and structure. The discussion raises concerns about whether this approach aligned with voter intent, especially given the earlier statewide vote.

The Core Promise: Funding Education

The CAT tax was promoted as a dedicated funding stream for education. Lawmakers repeatedly emphasized that the revenue would go directly to schools and improve outcomes.

However, the episode highlights a key issue: while CAT tax revenue was directed toward education funds, general fund contributions to K-12 education were reduced at the same time.

This resulted in what the hosts describe as a “bait-and-switch” dynamic, where:

  • New tax revenue replaced existing funding

  • Total increases did not match expectations

  • General fund dollars were redirected elsewhere

Education Outcomes: Are Students Succeeding?

A central question in the episode is whether increased funding has translated into better outcomes for students.

According to the discussion:

  • Student performance metrics have declined

  • Oregon ranks near the bottom nationally in key categories

  • Enrollment has dropped significantly since the CAT tax was implemented

One figure highlighted in the episode is a decline of over 34,000 students in public schools during this period.

At the same time:

  • Per-student spending has increased significantly

  • Oregon ranks among the top states in spending

  • Results have not improved proportionally

This disconnect between spending and outcomes is a major focus of the conversation.

The Cost to Businesses and Consumers

Another major theme is how the CAT tax impacts Oregon’s economy.

Because it is based on gross receipts:

  • Businesses with thin margins are disproportionately affected

  • Industries like agriculture, retail, and restaurants face compounding costs

  • Taxes are often passed down through the supply chain

As discussed in the episode, this creates a cascading effect:

Tax on production → tax on transport → tax on processing → tax on retail

Ultimately, this structure can increase prices for consumers while placing additional strain on small businesses.

Budget Growth and Accountability Concerns

The episode also highlights broader concerns about Oregon’s state budget.

Key points include:

  • The state budget has doubled in the past decade

  • It has quadrupled over the past two decades

  • New revenue streams have expanded government spending

Despite this growth, participants argue that accountability has not kept pace.

One concern raised is the lack of transparency around how funds are spent, particularly when money is directed to:

  • State agencies

  • Grant programs

  • Nonprofit organizations

Unlike government entities, many nonprofits are not subject to the same public records or accountability requirements, making it difficult to track outcomes.

The Bigger Issue: Governance and Transparency

Beyond the CAT tax itself, the episode points to a broader governance challenge in Oregon.

Complex budgeting systems, multiple funding streams, and limited auditing capacity make it difficult for the public to fully understand:

  • Where money is going

  • How effectively it is being used

  • Whether policies are achieving intended outcomes

The hosts argue that improving transparency and accountability is essential to restoring trust in government spending.

Looking Ahead

As Oregon approaches another election cycle, the discussion emphasizes the role voters play in shaping policy direction.

The CAT tax debate highlights several key questions for Oregonians:

  • Are current tax policies delivering results?

  • Is education funding producing better outcomes?

  • Is government spending aligned with public priorities?

Ultimately, the episode frames these issues as decisions for voters to evaluate at the ballot box.

Chapters

  • 02:40 Guest Introduction: Justin Brecht

  • 06:50 What the CAT Tax Really Is

  • 10:30 Voter Rejection of Measure 97

  • 13:10 Passing the CAT Tax in 2019

  • 17:00 The “Student Success Act” Promises

  • 20:00 Education Outcomes Since the Tax

  • 24:30 General Fund “Bait and Switch” Explained

  • 30:00 Charts and Data Breakdown

  • 36:00 COVID, Businesses, and the CAT Tax Impact

  • 42:00 Declining Enrollment and Rising Costs

  • 48:00 Federal Policy and Education Choices

  • 55:00 Medicaid Error Rates and Budget Pressure

  • 1:02:00 Oregon’s Growing State Budget

  • 1:06:30 Accountability and Nonprofit Spending

  • 1:08:30 Final Thoughts and Election Impact

Listen to the full audio episode