Health care

1:11:48

Who Would Pay for Oregon’s Universal Health Plan?

Justin Brecht

Legislative director, Oregon Senate Republican Office

ABOUT THIS EPISODE

What would Oregon’s proposed universal health plan mean for a family’s paycheck or a small business’s payroll? Mike McLane and Shelly Boshart Davis sit down with Justin Brecht to examine the five proposed taxes, the employer credit and the federal decisions that would shape the plan.

SHOW NOTES

A family of four earns $150,000 a year. What would Oregon’s proposed universal health plan cost them? Justin Brecht brings that example to this episode of Oregon Discussion. In the model he describes, the first $66,000 of that family’s income is exempt. He puts the household tax at roughly $844 a month before any employer tax credit. Comparing that figure with what the family pays today also means finding out what would happen to its insurance premiums.

That distinction runs through Brecht’s conversation with Senator Mike McLane and Representative Shelly Boshart Davis. All three want to know what happens when a statewide estimate reaches a particular household, business or hospital. Two neighbors earning the same amount could have different answers.

Where federal funding fits

Brecht, legislative director for the Oregon Senate Republican Office, explains the work of Oregon’s Universal Health Plan Governance Board. As he describes it at the time of recording, the financing model is still under discussion. It assumes that money already spent on health care can help fund a publicly financed plan.

McLane asks what that would mean for people with Medicare, Medicaid or military health coverage. A state legislator can vote on how Oregon raises money. The episode turns on a separate question about what federal officials would allow Oregon to do with federal health dollars. Boshart Davis asks who would cover a shortfall if the assumptions changed.

Five sources of revenue

Brecht names five parts of the financing model they reviewed. Two would reach most directly into working life through a household income tax and an employer payroll tax. The other three involve corporate income, corporate activity and lodging. The hosts take a moment to put the scale in perspective. Brecht discusses annual revenue estimates, while Oregon lawmakers write a two-year budget. The time period matters whenever the two figures appear side by side.

For households, income is only part of the calculation. Brecht describes a credit linked to what an employer contributes. Boshart Davis follows that idea to a practical question for two people doing similar work. If one takes a job with a small local business and the other takes a job with a larger employer, how does the difference show up on their returns?

A plumber, a restaurant and the next hire

The speakers work through the case of a self-employed plumber with a spouse and two children. Brecht starts with business profit, accounts for existing federal self-employment taxes and then estimates the modeled household tax. He adds a qualification to his own example. A fair comparison also needs the cost of the insurance the household would replace.

A restaurant brings a different set of numbers to the table. It may employ many people and operate on a thin margin. A tradesperson may have one employee and a much smaller payroll. A payroll threshold matters differently to each owner. Boshart Davis asks what happens when a shop grows enough to cross it. McLane adds that health benefits are one way employers compete for workers. The deductible and the employer’s contribution to a health savings account can matter to someone choosing between two jobs.

What voters approved and what lawmakers would decide

The conversation turns to Measure 111, Oregon’s constitutional provision on access to health care. The hosts debate what voters understood the measure to mean and what financing decisions would still have to come before legislators. Their questions are about both money and accountability. Who sets payment rates, who decides what care is available, and where does a patient go when a policy falls short?

Boshart Davis also asks why the model includes business and lodging taxes that account for relatively small shares of its revenue. She and McLane discuss how a tax on business activity can affect a company with little profit, and why adding a new use for a tax matters to the people already paying it.

What coverage means in Burns or John Day

Near the end, McLane asks listeners to picture a doctor weighing whether to stay in eastern Oregon when a spouse gets a job offer elsewhere. He points to Burns and John Day, where recruiting a physician is already difficult. For a patient there, the practical test of coverage is whether someone nearby can see them.

That brings the conversation back to savings. Which costs would fall, and how much of the reduction would come from hospitals, clinicians, drug spending or administration? Brecht closes by asking for more worked examples. A family with two paychecks, a self-employed tradesperson and a rural employer should each be able to trace what they pay now, what they would pay under a proposal and what care would be available in return.

In this episode

  • The five revenue sources the speakers examine and which two would raise the most money.

  • Brecht’s family-of-four example, the employer credit and the premium comparison.

  • Why payroll size and self-employment change the calculation for a business owner.

  • The federal waivers behind the model and the hosts’ questions about Measure 111.

  • Where savings might come from and what payment changes could mean for rural providers.

Chapters

  • 00:00 Coming Up

  • 01:27 What is universal health care?

  • 04:40 Justin Brecht on the plan Oregon is designing

  • 08:38 Federal waivers, Medicare, Medicaid and military coverage

  • 15:20 How the estimate compares with Oregon’s two-year budget

  • 19:26 Five proposed taxes and how the income tax would work

  • 24:52 What a family of four might pay before credits

  • 31:53 Payroll taxes, small employers and the self-employed plumber

  • 39:49 What would patients get in return?

  • 43:12 Corporate taxes and the cost of doing business

  • 45:59 Measure 111 and the right to affordable care

  • 56:25 Why include a lodging tax?

  • 59:57 Rural doctors, hospitals and the search for savings

  • 1:03:42 Who might move, who might stay and what the model should show

Further reading

Oregon Universal Health Plan Governance Board meeting materials