Episode 42

Business

1:12:20

Why Oregon’s Business Climate Is Falling Behind

Angela Wilhelms

Oregon Business & Industry

ABOUT THIS EPISODE

In this episode of Oregon D.O.G.E., Mike McLane and Shelly Boshart-Davis sit down with Angela Wilhelms, president and CEO of Oregon Business & Industry, to examine why Oregon’s economic competitiveness is slipping. The conversation covers taxes, regulation, budget growth, unemployment, and what state leaders would need to change to rebuild a healthier private sector.

SHOW NOTES

Why Oregon’s Business Climate Is Falling Behind — And What It Means for the State’s Future

Oregon’s economy does not run on slogans. It runs on jobs, investment, risk-taking, production, and the long-term health of the private sector. That was the core message in this Oregon D.O.G.E. episode featuring Angela Wilhelms, president and CEO of Oregon Business & Industry, who joined Mike McLane and Shelly Boshart-Davis for a detailed conversation about why Oregon is losing ground in business competitiveness and what that means for families, workers, and taxpayers across the state.

The discussion was not framed as a partisan rant. It was framed as a warning about trends: rising unemployment, declining business rankings, growing regulatory burdens, and a state budget that has expanded dramatically while many Oregonians feel they are not receiving a matching level of service. Angela Wilhelms argued that everything the state wants to accomplish — from public services to infrastructure to social programs — depends on a healthy private sector generating jobs, wages, philanthropy, and tax revenue.

Why the Private Sector Matters

One of the clearest themes in the episode is that Oregon cannot fund public priorities without a functioning and competitive private economy. Wilhelms notes that the private sector provides roughly 1.7 million jobs in Oregon and generates the economic activity that underwrites tax revenue at every level of government. The warning from OBI is that state policymakers have increasingly treated private-sector health as secondary, and in some cases have become openly hostile to the businesses that sustain the broader system.

That matters because Oregon is not competing in a vacuum. It is competing with other states for employers, workers, capital, and investment. If Oregon becomes less attractive to do business in, the result is not just lower corporate margins. It is fewer jobs, reduced upward mobility, weaker local tax bases, and less flexibility to pay for state priorities in the future. This episode argues that the health of Oregon’s business climate is not a niche issue. It is central to the state’s overall direction.

Oregon’s Declining Business Rankings

A major part of the episode focuses on rankings that illustrate Oregon’s recent decline. Wilhelms points to CNBC’s business ranking and notes that Oregon fell from 17th to 39th in less than a decade. She also highlights Oregon’s drop in tax competitiveness, saying the state ranked 7th as recently as 2019 and had fallen to 35th after a series of policy changes. Those changes include the corporate activity tax, new payroll taxes tied to paid leave, and a broader rise in the effective business tax burden. According to the discussion, Oregon’s effective business tax burden rose by 33 percent between 2019 and 2023.

The episode argues that these are not random fluctuations. They are the result of policy choices. That point is important because it means Oregon’s position is not inevitable. If lawmakers created the current environment through legislation and regulatory expansion, they can also reverse course with different decisions. That is one of the central messages of the conversation: the state’s wounds are self-inflicted, which is troubling, but also means reform is possible.

Jobs, Unemployment, and a Weakening Growth Story

Another major issue raised in the episode is Oregon’s labor market. Wilhelms says Oregon had the third-highest unemployment rate in the country at the time of the conversation and was experiencing year-over-year job loss in several key private-sector industries. Sectors such as manufacturing, construction, agriculture, financial services, and professional services were all described as losing jobs, while the only sectors showing growth were hospitality, health care, and government.

That distinction matters. Hospitality is still recovering from the pandemic. Health care, while necessary, is often funded indirectly by the rest of the economy. Government employment also depends on tax revenue generated elsewhere. In contrast, manufacturing and other traded-sector industries create new wealth, often pay above-average wages, and strengthen the state’s tax base. Wilhelms notes that manufacturing jobs pay about 17 percent more on average than other jobs, making the decline in that sector especially concerning.

The podcast presents this as a long-term opportunity problem for Oregon. If the state does not create conditions where private employers can expand and hire, younger workers and families will continue looking elsewhere. That means not just slower growth, but also a hollowing-out effect that impacts communities, schools, local businesses, and state finances.

The Regulatory Burden on Oregon Business

The episode also zeroes in on regulation. Wilhelms says Oregon is the seventh most regulated state in the country by volume and compares Oregon’s environmental and sector-specific rules with states like Washington. Even where the two states may share similar policy goals, Oregon often has a more fragmented and burdensome regulatory structure. In the examples discussed, Oregon was described as having nearly four times the number of regulations on hospitals as the U.S. median and nearly eight times the number of regulations affecting manufacturing.

This is not presented as an argument for eliminating all regulation. Rather, the argument is that Oregon lacks sufficient review, pruning, and accountability. The guests discuss possible reforms such as sunset provisions, legislative review committees for agency rulemaking, and an “arbitrary and capricious” legal standard to ensure regulations are tied to clear statutory authority and rational decision-making. According to Wilhelms, most states already use such standards, but Oregon does not.

The broader criticism is that Oregon layers program after program onto employers and consumers without regularly asking whether older rules are outdated, duplicative, or economically damaging. In that sense, the issue is not only regulation. It is governance. The episode frames regulatory reform as basic maintenance for a state that has allowed its rulebook to expand without enough ongoing scrutiny.

Budget Growth and the Accountability Question

One of the strongest fiscal arguments in the episode concerns Oregon’s budget. Wilhelms states that Oregon’s all-funds budget has quadrupled since 2001 and that the state is now the third-highest in per-capita state and local spending, behind only two states with sovereign wealth funds. She also says the General Fund for the current biennium is balanced with $3.4 billion in reserves and a $200 million ending fund, arguing that lawmakers did not need to raise taxes in the current cycle.

The political point behind those figures is straightforward: if state spending has increased this dramatically, why do so many Oregonians still feel dissatisfied with schools, public safety, homelessness policy, and basic service delivery? The episode frames that gap as a major accountability problem. It is not only a question of how much government spends. It is a question of whether the public is seeing meaningful results.

This becomes even more relevant in the context of future budget pressure. The guests discuss the likelihood that Oregon will face pressure to backfill declining federal funds in future sessions. Wilhelms argues that trying to solve that problem by extracting more money from an already strained private sector will not work. In her view, the only sustainable answer is to grow the pie by creating more private-sector jobs and making Oregon more competitive for investment and expansion.

Three Steps: Acknowledge, Stop Digging, Build the Ladder

One of the most memorable framing devices in the episode is Wilhelms’ three-part approach. First, policymakers need to acknowledge the problem. Second, they need to stop digging the hole deeper. Third, they need to do the work of building a ladder out. That framework becomes a shorthand for how OBI sees the state’s current condition: Oregon is in a hole economically, and many officials still have not fully admitted it.

On the first step, Wilhelms says ordinary Oregonians largely understand that the state is on the wrong track, but policymakers are lagging behind. On the second step, she argues the most recent session failed the “do no harm” test and deepened the problem rather than pausing it. On the third step, she says there were only limited efforts to improve permitting and related processes, but not enough to count as a serious competitiveness agenda.

That framing matters because it keeps the conversation from drifting into cynicism. The argument is not just that Oregon is struggling. It is that Oregon still has a path forward if state leaders are willing to shift course, modernize systems, and prioritize job creation and private-sector growth as core public-policy goals.

What This Means for Oregon Voters

The hosts close by emphasizing that 2026 is an election year and that Oregon voters ultimately decide what kind of future the state will pursue. The podcast repeatedly returns to the disconnect between public dissatisfaction and legislative output. If voters are unhappy with rising costs, weak job growth, declining competitiveness, and the quality of state services, then elections are the mechanism through which they can demand different priorities.

That does not mean every policy debate is simple. Tax structure, land use, regulation, and budget planning are complicated subjects. But the episode’s central argument is simple enough for any voter to understand: Oregon cannot regulate, tax, and spend its way into prosperity if the underlying private economy is not healthy. If state government wants to deliver strong services, it first has to create conditions where private employers, workers, and entrepreneurs can thrive.

Conclusion

This episode of Oregon D.O.G.E. offers a clear warning about the direction of Oregon’s economy. Angela Wilhelms makes the case that the state’s weakening business climate is not an abstract concern for lobbyists or trade groups. It affects jobs, wages, affordability, public services, and the long-term ability of Oregon to compete with other states. The conversation challenges the assumption that more spending and more regulation automatically produce better outcomes. Instead, it asks whether Oregon is getting the results its taxpayers are paying for — and whether state leaders are willing to change course before the hole gets deeper.

Chapters

  • 01:15 Mike and Shelly Open the Episode

  • 04:17 Meet Angela Wilhelms of OBI

  • 09:33 The Real State of Oregon’s Business Climate

  • 11:05 Why a Healthy Private Sector Matters

  • 13:05 Oregon’s Drop in Tax Competitiveness

  • 17:07 Oregon Falls in National Business Rankings

  • 19:20 Job Loss, Unemployment, and Weak Growth

  • 21:20 Why Manufacturing Jobs Matter

  • 23:02 Warning Signs Oregon Can’t Ignore

  • 28:52 Stop Digging the Hole Deeper

  • 31:34 Tax Disconnect and Policy Frustration

  • 37:54 What Real Economic Reform Would Require

  • 41:55 Oregon’s Regulatory Burden Explained

  • 46:09 The Arbitrary and Capricious Standard Debate

  • 50:00 Climate Rules, Fuel Costs, and Consumer Impact

  • 55:09 Grading Oregon’s Economic Leadership

  • 1:03:01 Budget Pressure and the Fight Over Revenue

  • 1:06:27 Oregon’s Budget Has Quadrupled

  • 1:09:26 Are Oregonians Getting What They Pay For?

  • 1:10:14 The Election-Year Choice Ahead

Listen to the full audio episode